Privatisation at heart of NI Water scandal

Contracting Out is a company headed by Sue Holmes, a senior consultant adviser to NI Water. This outsourcing company was awarded a contract by NI Water without any competition from other firms involving 130 days work by the firm at £775 a day, amounting to £100,000 of public money. On top of this, Holmes’ company had a 6% “success fee” for “savings identified” (not actual savings) of which she had claimed to have identified savings of £23m!

However, this was not a once-off. Contracts signed with private companies with close links to senior managers at NI Water were often repeatedly renewed without review. Consultants also received lucrative payments. As previously reported in The Socialist, a Public Accounts Committee review has shown NI Water has been riddled with corruption. The review identified 73 contracts awarded by NI Water where rules regarding competitive tendering were not followed, worth £28.4 million in total. This included one consultancy item over £750,000 which was not checked by the NI Water board or the Department for Regional Development.

This resulted in the firing of four non-executive members of NI water board who received a massive £500,000 in bonus and fees in three years! However, as Jamie Delargy’s report on UTV Live Tonight makes clear, the firing of these non-executive directors were “fall guys” for what is a systematic problem. This trail of corruption has led to the suspension of DRD Permanent Secretary Paul Priestly. Priestly was removed for suspected interfering into an ongoing “independent” investigation including drafting a letter for Phoenix Energy chief executive Peter Dixon threatening MLAs with legal action.

Although the full picture of this sordid affair has yet to be revealed (it is thought much more is to come out), it is an absolute vindication of what the Socialist Party and the anti-water charges We Won’t Pay Campaign warned when NI Water was established in 2007. We warned that water charges and the creation of NI Water was part of a process towards the privatisation of the water service. Bosses from private companies were given huge salaries to takeover our water service –who then began to hand out contracts to their profit-hungry business friends.

The newly appointed non-executive directors have largely remained silent about the recent scandals with the exception of Mairtin O’Muilleoir who has been vocal on his blog defending his colleagues. O’Muilleoir is a Belfast businessman, Chief Executive of Andersonstown News Group and a former Sinn Fein councillor. Instead of dealing with the scandals he has ranted about the SDLP controlled media having an agenda and harks back to the days when “self-styled Catholic elite teamed up with the Brits to freeze out republicans from jobs and community posts.” Writing while on holidays in Hawaii, he concluded his blog post by saying “Nowadays, thank God, those appointed to public office have to prove their worth”. One has to ask how exactly is he proving his worth or has O’Muilleoir become part of the “self-styled Catholic elite” he claims to despise?

Many trade union and anti-water charges activists have followed with interest the appointment of ICTU Assistant General Secretary Peter Bunting as one of the non-executive directors of NI Water. The only statement Bunting has made (as a member of the new board of directors) has been to back the current Chief Executive Lawrence McKenzie, a former boss of Phoenix Gas.

Instead of taking director positions, the trade union leadership should be demanding that NI Water be immediately brought back into public hands, and run democratically by elected bodies representing workers and local communities and public representatives. The profiteers should be removed from our water service, with all workers directly employed in the public sector.

Previous Article

Sinn Fein criticised for grandstanding on cuts

Next Article

Review: Labour in Irish History - One hundred years of a socialist classic

Related Posts

Belgium government plans to ban the burqa

Constant stigmatisation of Muslim population

On 29 April, Belgium’s lower house of parliament voted for a law that would ban women from wearing the full Islamic face veil in public – the burqa (a loose garment, usually with veiled holes for the eyes, worn by Muslim women ). The law now goes to the Senate. If passed, the ban would be the first move of its kind in Europe. If the ban is eventually passed, women who defy it will be subject to fines of 15-25 euros and even 7 days in prison.


Get your new copy of ‘The Health Worker’

The Health Worker
Written for health workers by health workers - August 2010

In this issue:
- Stop the health cuts - Staff say "We've had enough!"
- Crisis in Nursing
- Unions must call major demo

Have you any issues for The Health Worker?
If you would like to highlight an issue or you would like copies to distribute at work, then contact Pat Lawlor on 07810522111 or email -

Click here to download your copy


US – Fight for Full LGBT Equality!

Being an LGBT person means facing discrimination in the workplace, bullying at school and in many cases from family members, not being able to marry your loved one legally, and being faced with higher rates of suicide and homelessness (between 20 and 40 percent of homeless youth identify as LGBT).