George Lee & De Burca Fly Away

In the vast acreage of print devoted to last week’s two political retirees, former parliamentarians George Lee and Deirdre de Burca, there was little recognition of the real lessons which are, that personality politics holds nothing in the way of a solution to either our economic or political problems and secondly that ordinary people should not put any faith in establishment political parties or politicians. For some the spectacle was highly amusing. As the air thickened with recrimination between the pair and their political parties, for some reason the writer Flann O’Brien came strongly to mind. Perhaps it was that I remembered reading that his fractious relationship with his political masters caused him to resign amid, it was said memorably, ‘a cacophony of f**ks.’ Or maybe it was a subconscious association of the departees with the title of one of his famous books, ‘At Swim Two Birds.’

Certainly there was no end of feathers and shrill accusations flying as the two abandoned the party nests. Sailors once believed that a sighting of stormy petrels heralded a severe storm. Last week it was the two petrels themselves who were making heavy waves for their former colleagues.

How differently it all began. Nine months ago George Lee began his political journey, not as petrel but soaring eagle, elevated to dizzy heights by a celebrity crazed media and the updraughts of his own lofty rhetoric about changing the world for the children and grand children of the nation.

His admirers believed that eagle George had an unrivalled perspective on the battered landscape that is the Irish capitalist economy and could transform it into a happy valley where milk and honey flowed again.
Apparently George believed this also and set about educating Fine Gael and leader Enda Kenny. No eagle Enda, however. More the crafty wren from Aesop’s fable who hides in the eagle’s plumage and is raised to dizzying heights never before experienced.

We do not know if Deirdre de Burca ever imagined herself as a soaring eagle in the Green firmament but unfortunately she finished up as barnyard fowl grubbing for some elusive pickings in the EU’s foraging patch.
In a frank admission in an article in The Irish Times,Ms de Burca reveals that it was the failure of Party Leader Gormley to secure a plum job in the cabinet of new EU Commissioner Geoghegan Quinn, that was the catalyst for her resignation and walk out. Apparently this job had been promised by Taoiseach Cowen only for Gormley to inform her that she had subsequently been ‘shafted by Fianna Fail.’

‘This was the point at which I knew that it was time for me to resign from the parliamentary party and from the Government,’ declared Ms de Burca. What an extraordinary revelation of cynical self seeking, indicating just how badly members of the green Party have lost the moral compass they claimed to treasure.

The Green Party in government could vote for fundamental injustices. Like savaging the incomes of low and middle income workers and social welfare recipients. Like mortgaging present and future generations to the banks and the speculator bondholders, the greedy authors of the economic catastrophe. However, it was the failure to land a lucrative job, gifted by the political establishment, far away from the victims of the economic crash and the Fianna Fail/Green Party Government’s harsh medicine that opened the eyes of the departing Senator.

As for George Lee we have to look on his brief political trajectory with equal scepticism. What exactly did he stand for? What was his solution to the economic crisis which is blighting the lives of so many? What was it that he had in mind that Fine Gael would apparently not take on board?

Unfortunately we do not know the answers to these questions because George Lee did not tell us. One would imagine that he would have committed his ideas to paper and published a manifesto. He could have gone to the ranks of his new party and argued for this manifesto to be adopted by them as its General Election policy. Failing that he could have appealed directly to the people.

The reality is that, if clearly outlined, George Lee’s prescriptions for the economic crisis would be largely the same as those of both Fianna Fail and Fine Gael and based on the premise that the dictates of the gods of the financial markets at whose altar they all worship, would have to be obeyed. And whether Greece or Ireland, Spain or Portugal, that means savage attacks on the living standards of working people, savage attacks on working conditions and pension entitlements. Because George Lee shares the same assumptions that underpin the dominant economic system. And it is only by fundamentally challenging that system itself that solutions will be found.

Total
0
Shares
Previous Article

Mass Action not Individual terror

Next Article

Greece - Hundreds of thousands join public sector strike against savage austerity plans

Related Posts

Afghanistan – Insurgency, poverty and corruption

Taliban insurgency, poverty and corruption

Afghanistan. Western strategy in tatters

By Niall Mullholland

Another grisly milestone has been reached in Afghanistan: over 300 British soldiers have now died, since the war began in 2001. The average age of those killed is 22.

No such records are kept of civilian deaths in Afghanistan. It is estimated that thousands of Afghan civilians have been directly killed due to military action, including use of air strikes by the US forces. As well as this, possibly tens of thousands of Afghan civilians have died indirectly from the war, as a consequence of displacement, starvation, disease, exposure, lack of medical treatment and violent crime.

The fact that the British forces’ death rate this year is twice that of 2006 shows the UK and US’s war plans are going awry in this unwinnable and unjustified war. This strategic failure lies behind David Cameron’s comment at the recent G20 summit that British forces “can’t be there for another five years.”

The Permanent Revolution today

We publish below a new introduction by Peter Taaffe to Leon Trotsky’s ‘Permanent Revolution’, which the comrades of Socialist Movement Pakistan (CWI) are to translate into Urdu and publish.

Introduction to new Urdu edition of ‘Permanent Revolution’ by Leon Trotsky

What relevance does Trotsky’s Theory of the Permanent Revolution have to the problems of the workers’ cause or the peasants’ (small farmers) movement today? After all, it was formulated more than 100 years ago during the first Russian revolution of 1905-07. The same kind of question could be posed – and it is – regarding the ideas of Marx and Engels, Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg. But no matter how ‘old’ is an idea – a method of analysis upon which mass action is based – if it more accurately describes the situation today than ‘new’ theories, it retains all its relevance in the modern era. This is particularly the case for the masses in the neo-colonial world – and especially today in the vital country of Pakistan with more than 200 million inhabitants – confronted as they are with all the terrible problems flowing from the incomplete capitalist-democratic revolution.

Civil service 2009 pay final offer

Following the rejection of an initial offer for 2009 Northern Ireland civil service pay in April, NIPSA has now received an improved final offer. The union has embarked on a 3-week consultation with their civil service branches with members attending pay meetings and voting whether to accept or reject the offer. The Civil Service Executive Committee which has a Broad Left majority has reluctantly recommended the offer to members. However we do not describe this as a good offer or even a fair one and falls far short of our 2009 claim.

 

South Africa: 5,000 sacked miners on strike

On Saturday 26 June I travelled with two comrades from South Africa's Democratic Socialist Movement (DSM, the Socialist Party's counterpart in South Africa) to a mass meeting they had called in Rustenburg, about two hours north west of Johannesburg.

The city of Rustenburg is home to 400,000 people and is best known to Australians as the host of several World Cup games at the Royal Bafokeng Stadium.