Demand the right to choose


Twenty years ago there was a case in Ireland were a fourteen year old girl became pregnant after being raped by her neighbour. The High Court prevented her from travelling to England for an abortion. Two weeks on after a public outcry at this decision, the Supreme Court allowed her to the right to an abortion in England on the grounds that there was a danger to her life because of the risk of suicide. This case was called the X Case.



Twenty years on from this, Socialist Party/United Left Alliance (ULA) TD Clare Daly proposed a Bill to the Dail to legislate for the X Case. It was entitled Medical Treatment (Termination of Pregnancy in Case of Risk to life of Pregnant Women) Bill 2012. This Bill last April was defeated.

Currently the law concerning this area is such a legal quagmire that doctors are unclear of the circumstances under which a woman should be entitled to have an abortion in Ireland both North and South. This leads to a situation were women who are already facing the difficulty of carrying a pregnancy that presents a risk to their life are forced to experience the added trauma of having to travel outside of the State to receive abortion services a position that they can’t always afford to do so.

There will be a pro-life rally in Belfast on the 7th July which will further victimise women who have made or are in the process of making the difficult decision of whether to terminate a pregnancy. The Socialist Party will be part of staging a counter rally which is pro-choice.

The Socialist Party believes all women in Ireland should be given the immediate right to access free, safe and legal abortion provided through a public service with access to appropriate counselling services.

The State does not have the right to dictate to women when and if they should have children. The State’s decision to ban abortion just creates a class divide in access to safe abortion.

The average cost for a woman to travel to England for an abortion including travel costs is estimated to be in excess of £2000. Money many women can’t get hold of in time causing the stress of a later abortion, an unwanted child being born or one that the mother can’t afford to bring up or an unsafe backstreet abortion.

Many women’s choices to have children are affected by the capitalist system’s austerity cuts that cause poverty, low pay, unemployment, cuts in benefits, expensive childcare etc.

Women need to be supported in their struggle to defend their rights in their choice of whether and when to have children or not. A fight that the unions should also be taking up.


Previous Article


Next Article

Kick profit out of sport

Related Posts
Read More

Rape trial highlights sexism in legal system and society

The protests in the wake of the trial – which forced the sacking of Jackson and Olding by Ulster Rugby and have prompted a review into the conduct of such trials in the future – are the beginnings of a movement against misogyny, against victim blaming and against rape culture. We can link this to the wider movement against sexism worldwide, in particular across South America with the ‘Ni Una Menos’ movement and in Spain, with tens of thousands protesting across the country after the recent clearing of the ‘manada’ (wolf pack) of the gang rape of a young woman. It is imperative we continue to build this movement to win the fight in ending sexism, misogyny and oppression worldwide.
Read More

#IBelieveHer – ROSA statement on Ulster Rugby trial

The sexist attitudes that have dominated this trial show there is a need for special measures in order to ensure that victims of sexual violence receive justice. The example of specialised courts should be considered, as in South Africa and other countries, which provide judge and juries with training and have achieved a higher level of conviction and a less traumatic experience in court for victims of sexual violence.
Read More

Oxfam scandal: we need democratic aid and working class solidarity

In January 2010 when the earthquake struck we wrote: "The humanitarian catastrophe that has befallen Haiti beggars belief." Hundreds of thousands were killed and millions left homeless, injured, denied medicine and starving. The country had just two fire stations and no 'quake-proof' housing. Even before the earthquake 80% lived below the poverty line and three-quarters were out of work. Haitians were therefore extremely vulnerable. Our headline read, "a disaster compounded by capitalism".